@erik.sundvall mentioned that my generator could also generate OpenAPI schemas. I’ve spent the past few hours writing a generator of OpenAPI schemas from the BMM files. Please download the generated schemas and report what needs to be fixed: Download OpenAPI schemas I haven’t implemented generic…

Very cool work done in half a day @borut.jures ! Are you planning to generate JSON schema also? (For tools that prefer that?) What about plans for simplified template-based OpenAPI/schema-files as discussed in: Separating Models from Implementation - #61 by erik.sundvall

[image] erik.sundvall: Very cool work done in half a day @borut.jures ! Thank you! [image] erik.sundvall: Are you planning to generate JSON schema also? (For tools that prefer that?) I believe the consensus was to go ahead with OpenAPI instead of JSON Schema . Lets see if the OpenAPI …

Cool work @borut.jures a next step I get exited about would be generating OpenAPI from a template. This one is simplish and useful: Clinical Knowledge Manager . If you want I can create an even simpler one for e.g. the BP result we talked about with @gary. Or an even simpler, but much less well d…

Thank you! [image] joostholslag: a next step I get exited about would be generating OpenAPI from a template Maybe I’ll do that after somebody presents what they did with OpenAPI for AM and RM models. The generated files aren’t usable as they are at the moment. I will know when somebody is s…

[image] borut.jures: Maybe I’ll do that after somebody presents what they did with OpenAPI for AM and RM models. The generated files aren’t usable as they are at the moment. The thing is that RM/AM is useful for already openEHR-savvy people creating openEHR tools and CDRs. Those that do that…

[image] borut.jures: Maybe what they are asking for isn’t the best approach (see the paragraph about using AM model instead of intermediary formats above). Sometimes cleaner architecture makes applications easier to develop, maintain and upgrade. Yes that is certainly true for some use cases.…

[image] erik.sundvall: What is missing I agree with @heath.frankel ’s comment. Many attempts were made to “simplify” OPTs and “protect” developers from learning openEHR AM/RM. None made them happy. My opinion is that if developers don’t want to familiarise themselves with the openEHR approach…

I don’t want to be disrespectful to anybody but I believe there is a minimum effort required before starting to build software. I wasn’t afraid of flying until: “The Max has been grounded since March 2019, after some badly written software caused two crashes that killed 346 people. And while Boeing…

[image] borut.jures: I don’t want to be disrespectful to anybody but I believe there is a minimum effort required before starting to build software There really is. People want the power of modern aircraft, mobile telephony, AI radiology assessments and video-conferencing, while also claiming…

[image] borut.jures: there is a minimum effort required before starting to build software I now tried to explain my concerns a bit more in post 77 of Separating Models from Implementation - #77 by erik.sundvall

OpenAPI schemas generated from BMM files

Implementation Platform

erik.sundvall (Erik Sundvall) 29 November 2021 08:59 9

Yes that is certainly true for some use cases. I am not sure what you are suggesting, but if it is to use paths in a way similar to what is described on a wikipage from 2012 by @thomas.beale https://openehr.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/spec/pages/4915205/Ocean+EhrGate+-+Composition+Builder+programming+example, then note @heath.frankel’s comment at the bottom of that page regarding what developers not familiar with openEHR thought:

Separating Models from Implementation

Topic		Replies	Views
EHRBase and ADL2.0 Platform adl , rest-apis , ehrbase	23	887	13 April 2024
Implementing BMM in other languages Platform	18	1602	11 November 2020
Separating Models from Implementation New to openEHR?	107	5976	11 December 2021
Using the openEHR Template Designer to create Clinical Document Definitions Template Designer	18	3148	19 September 2023
CONTRIBUTION builder supporting collaborative (multi user, multi device) editing? GraphQL? Operational Transformation? Implementation	9	1288	17 December 2021
Generation of Example Instances of a Template CKM	23	335	20 August 2024
Simplified JSON data formats for openEHR ITS sdt , json	21	4411	25 March 2021
REST API Specifications in OpenAPI format ITS rest , rest-apis	23	1199	29 November 2022
JSON Schema and OpenAPI: current state, and how to progress ITS rest-apis , json	40	4879	8 April 2025
Does openEHR recommends to define service APIs using openEHR models as resources/TOs Implementation	12	823	19 August 2021

OpenAPI schemas generated from BMM files

Related topics