[All: this is a long post on an important topic, so I’ve made it a wiki post i.e. directly editable by others. Feel free to make inline additions, but please try to retain the general integrity. I suggest to add your initials to any additions. Most likely we should create extra topics on each major …

It is good conversation but is probably mixing up the tech and the clinical semantics/governance. The tech that is not quite right for me is a simpler approach to references between Entry objects that allows Nesting of Entries including inside the same composition. Making Entries more Restful from…

[image] ian.mcnicoll: Nesting of Entries including inside the same composition. Can we clarify the sense in which you mean ‘nesting’ … do you mean: A: an Entry (primarily an Evaluation?) can refer to other previously recorded Entries, and the linked structure is visualised as a hierarchy? B…

I’ll add my technical 2 cents here, and let the others figure out the medico-legal and otherwise content-related aspects, and I’ll also send @borut.fabjan and @vanessap this way for that reason. From technical POV, I would only like to see a persisted copy of the data within those lists if there is…

[image] matijap: As there would probably be a widespread interest in having the CDR handle the assembly of the actual list (with contents, not just links), that should be handled in another way, e.g. another API endpoint, and a server-side function or similar for AQL. Then it would be up to impl…

I’m starting to think that Citation may not be needed, with a little bit of work on the LINK class. What are people’s views on making more use of uids vs. full AQL paths, at least at runtime, and emulating the CDA/FHIR approach of allowing in-composition local references?

If I fall under the “people” category, I must say I didn’t understand the question. :slight_smile: Could you elaborate?

To my understanding, we would have to do this anyway if we need to link to a specific entry inside compositions with repeating paths. I gave it some thought that this should be a configuration of EHRbase to automatically create uids if an entry’s path inside a particular composition is not unique.

@matijap - sorry - I was being a bit confusing. Fir ‘id’ I was raising the issue that I see increasing use of the ENTRY.uid or sometimes ENTRY.event.uid, either for internal references or to identify the ENTRY or (sub-ENTRY like event) to line-up with FHIR. e.g how do you gnerate a FHIR.id for an OB…

[image] ian.mcnicoll: increasing use of the ENTRY.uid or sometimes ENTRY.event.uid, either for internal references or to identify the ENTRY or (sub-ENTRY like event) to line-up with FHIR. e.g how do you gnerate a FHIR.id for an OBSERVATION? I think eventually mandating or strongly recommendin…

[image] ian.mcnicoll: I’m starting to think that Citation may not be needed, with a little bit of work on the LINK class The changes that we would need to propose on LINK would be the same ones that CITATION brings - primarily an attribute containing the resolved target of the LINK on retriev…

Cross-reference, citations and a solution for managed lists

Specifications RM

joostholslag (Joost Holslag) 26 April 2021 08:17 18

Another use-case example. Mayo score - ready for publication - #8 by joostholslag

Topic		Replies	Views
How accurately do we model "copied" data? Clinical	42	1664	27 August 2025
Missing rule in AOM 1.4 for non-unique sibling nodeIds Specifications	42	1066	8 April 2024
Could the specs group consider making uid mandatory? Technical (archive)	20	109	20 December 2016
Named element - and occurences Archetype Designer	71	1803	29 January 2023
openEHR artefact namespace identifiers Technical (archive)	26	142	29 April 2011
Use of Identifiers in archetypes Technical (archive)	19	86	19 January 2011
13606 revisited - list proposal Technical (archive)	71	251	28 March 2012
Usage of Blood glucose archetype for self-monitoring Clinical (archive)	52	329	14 December 2012
Problem-oriented records and querying by problem Technical (archive)	34	149	30 January 2015
CIMI archetype examples using latest openEHR AOM & ADL Technical (archive)	33	128	20 February 2014

Cross-reference, citations and a solution for managed lists

Related topics