What do you think about the following logic related to AQL? The following AQLs will be intepreted as logical equals for the AQL engine. The first AQL 1.0 is a short hand query for the full AQL defined as AQL 1.3. The examples is given here: openehr-conformance/aql/index.adoc at master · bjornna/op…

Sorry for being unclear :slight_smile: The question is if you agree that the given AQL’s will produce identical results. The given AQLs are, in our opinion, equal. They are different syntactic variants of the same maximal AQL given in AQL 1.3. Take a look at the original page for more details abou…

they are all equal assuming the most common interpretation of CONTAINS semantics, which you’ve made explicit in 1.3.

They look functionally equivalent (or at least quite close) to me. But I have few small questions: one is about not using “EHR e”, is that allowed? will that assume there is an EHR somewhere in the context? or is it implying all EHR available on system? in the AQL there is nothing like VERSIONED_…

syntactically, not having EHR is OK. We have a dedicated… “festival” going on regarding the definition of FROM, as you know :slight_smile: The syntax of AQL currently requires that you have a single root in the FROM clause, as in FROM X… Again syntactically, that X can be any RM type with/without …

[image] bna: CONTAINS VERSION v[latest_version] Is ‘latest_version’ predicate supported by AQL?

[image] pablo: Is ‘latest_version’ predicate supported by AQL? We assume so: //<VersionPredicateOptions> ::= 'latest_version' | 'all_versions' versionPredicateOptions : 'latest_version' | ALL_VERSIONS; See AQL syntax specification

AQL - same logical AQL with different syntax

Specifications AQL

sebastian.iancu (Sebastian Iancu) 24 February 2020 20:37 2

I’m sorry, but I’m not sure what is the question (the catch) here. Can you rephrase it?

Topic		Replies	Views
Questions on AQL CONTAINS formalism AQL	7	219	12 September 2024
Specifying and implementing AQL CONTAINS AQL aql	2	650	28 March 2020
AQL question about predicates AQL	4	699	2 March 2020
AQL - what do you expect as results for these example AQL	6	566	16 November 2020
AQL questions Technical (archive)	5	34	30 April 2019
[openEHR SEC] AQL FROM & CONTAINS with many entries Technical (archive)	6	22	1 October 2017
AQL- New feature suggestion: descendant paths AQL aql	11	603	18 February 2020
AQL semantics: separating RM semantics from AQL semantics AQL	4	431	17 November 2020
What is a query on VERSION v returning ? Specifications	19	263	15 January 2026
AQL query writing question Implementers (archive)	1	24	8 October 2018

AQL - same logical AQL with different syntax

Related topics